The official DWI judge

Crza · Posted: Wed Jun 11, 2003 9:45 am Post subject: The official DWI judge

Basically this thread is for anyone who has made a custom DWI that they think is so good that it should be in a real DDR game. Basically here are the rules:

1) Only submit a request for one song at a time. After your song is judged, you can request another one.

2) Some of your songs may not be judged at all. As of right now it's only me judging them. And I don't have all day to be doing this. So sorry if I miss a couple.

3) Notice the forum is called the official DWI judge. Note that this means that any kind of criticism can be given, whether it be constructive or destructive. So if you're giving me one, make sure it's good or I will shout to the heavens, "This sucks AZZ!!!" if I find it necessary. Be aware of this while posting.

4) Plz just post links to pages with your song on them. Don't post anything else.

5) Update to concede with the rules - Ok, if you wanna post ur opinion about a judge's decision, go ahead. But chances are it won't be replied to unless it has a valid argument.

6) Do not PM me with songs I should review or any arguments about songs. I just don't care. If I get bogged up with mail about songs I should get, I'll take locking this up into consideration.

7) If you can abide by the rules, I'm sure you'll have a good time. Enjoy!

I'm still looking for more people for a panel. Right now I only need 2 more. If you wanna do it, PM me. But be aware that you will need to spend a significant time on here so that this stays up. And if anyone wants to put up any news on Tournamixes or whatever. PM me and I'll post it up here. Thx!
_________________

onoessnaked · Staff Member Joined: 22 Aug 2002 Location: UK

Ooh. Tournamix on a smaller scale

_________________

Well, it explains the disappearance

Phrekwenci · Administrator Joined: 27 Feb 2002 Location: New York, NY

CoreyBlaze · Trick Member Joined: 11 Mar 2002 Location: Puerto Rico

Judge my version of Zero-One, look for it on the latest page of the topic "get your .dwis and .crs here". I'd appreciate some comments.

Phrekwenci · Administrator Joined: 27 Feb 2002 Location: New York, NY

Hell, judge everyones Zero One, while your at it.
_________________

Best thread on DDR Freak winnar | Second best thread | Posting and You...

eViL_bOrIs_Beethoven · Trick Member Joined: 20 Oct 2002 Location: Lakewood, NJ

I'll join your board. I think I've played enough dwi's (290 as of yet) to be qualified. And I love to criticize people

_________________

www.gamehippo.com - Quite possibly the worlds largest source of freeware

onoessnaked · Staff Member Joined: 22 Aug 2002 Location: UK

I don't have a version of Zero One

(Is it like, some pre-requisite or something? "You must have a version of Zero One or you can't call yourself a DWI-maker"?

)
_________________

Well, it explains the disappearance

Phrekwenci · Administrator Joined: 27 Feb 2002 Location: New York, NY

onoessnaked · Staff Member Joined: 22 Aug 2002 Location: UK

...I have a version of SOS (The Tiger Stole my Family) ...Does that count?

*hopeful*
_________________

Well, it explains the disappearance

EvilDave219 · Posted: Thu Jun 12, 2003 12:06 pm Post subject:

Here is my favorite DWI:
Maxx Resurexxtion
(Note, I didn't make this, DJ Demon did so give him the credit)

This sounds sooo much better than all the Maxxes on real DDR mixes. You have to try it out. I am 100% sure you will like it, even if you hate all other Max songs.
_________________

pfffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff

[R] · Posted: Thu Jun 12, 2003 1:32 pm Post subject:

CoreyBlaze · Trick Member Joined: 11 Mar 2002 Location: Puerto Rico

Crza · Posted: Thu Jun 12, 2003 9:53 pm Post subject:

Damn, I didn't check back thinkin that no one would reply but it seems like ppl like it so ill get crackin' on Zero One I guess. (Am I sensing hostility, Phrekwenci?

)
And I've long since had Maxx Ressurection for a long while. Yes it is the best original Max, but I think LoM is better. Something with MaxxRes.'s steps are a tiny bit weird and I can't hit them sometimes. Really, sometimes. Other times I can hit it. This song tho should definitely be in DDR tho. It passes.
Phrekwenci, I'm dling Zero one right now, I'll come back and edit this post when I'm finished. But if you wanna do a little judging yourself, I have only 1 DWI that I have made so far (I'm kinda busy with DDR History 2), it's called Multiplayer Battle on Bemanisims. Why don't you dl it and tell me what you think...
Evil Boris whatever, sure you can join the board, just try and do as much as you can. But from now on to everyone, just PM me if you wanna join.

Edit Ok I played ZeroOne. First of all, PerfectAsymetry - WHAT WERE YOU THINKING? They felt too weird and off key. You should definitely revamp those steps. They don't go with the music well. IMHO, it wouldn't be in a DDR mix.
Phrekwenci - Hmmmm, you can't really enjoy a song unless you thoroughly analyze how the steps go with the beat. It seems that you attempted to do that with every arrow. If I could summarize your steps, it would be Xenon and So Deep's illegitamate child. I enjoyed your steps the second time around, and yes I could see this in a DDR mix. Your steps pass. Happy now?

_________________

G-Dragon · Trick Member Joined: 25 Jan 2002

http://www.bemanisims.com/?loc=file.php&id=2569
http://www.bemanisims.com/?loc=file.php&id=3024
http://www.bemanisims.com/?loc=file.php&id=3162

_________________

Crza · Posted: Thu Jun 12, 2003 10:53 pm Post subject:

Ok I've played Dark Sam's version of Zero-One and I must say that his steps are a lot more fun than Phrek's. They're a lot easier also. But here's where the realism factors in. Xenon was in Extreme, if you're gonna put in an un named copy (like DXY! and Stoic, they're basically the same song), you gotta make it around the same difficulty or harder. Still tho, it would make it in there.

Good Cool, I'll get to you later, it's bedtime now.

OK NEW RULES! One submission at a time (*cough Good-Cool), wait for someone to judge the file, THEN put up another one. I don't have enough time to be doing all of these. And let's plz try to limit posting files that aren't yours. I'm not saying don't (yet) but try to keep it to a minimum.
_________________

Rage* · Trick Member Joined: 19 Aug 2002 Location: Northy West UK

i wouldnt mind opinions on mine.

www.ragemix.tk
_________________

PlatinumHawke · Trick Member Joined: 18 Mar 2002

http://www.bemanisims.com/?loc=file.php&id=2958

Tell me, based on playing this with your feet, is this an 8 or a 9? I'm not rightfully sure, and nobody gives comments on files over on BemaniSims... damn leeches....

PerfectAsymmetry · Staff Member Joined: 24 Jan 2002 Location: Brooklyn, NY

Phrekwenci · Administrator Joined: 27 Feb 2002 Location: New York, NY

Crza · Posted: Fri Jun 13, 2003 5:08 pm Post subject:

Ok on my browser, Bemanisims is down for the moment, so I can't judge any of them (Where you at Boris?). And GoNinja, I take it you didn't read the last few posts so I'll reiterate, only one song at a time, there's no way I'm doin that much. I guess I'll just edit the first post then...

Phrekwenci - Yah you're right, u did say the challenge steps. ( I think I know why...) So when are you gonna judge mine then massa?
_________________